uninteresting； or unnecessarily verbose。
〃Your Honour and Gentlemen of the Jury： John Darrow was murdered and
the prisoner； M。 Gustave Latour； has confessed that he did the deed。
When a man denies the commission of a crime we do not feel bound to
consider his testimony of any particular value； but when； on the
other hand； a prisoner accused of so heinous a crime as murder
responds to the indictment； 'I am guilty；' we instinctively feel
impelled to believe his testimony。 Why is this？ Why do we doubt
his word when he asserts his innocence and accept it when he
acknowledges his guilt？ I will tell you。 It is all a question of
motive。 Could we see as cogent a motive for asseverating his guilt
as we find for his insisting upon his innocence； we should lend as
much credence to the one as to the other。 I propose to show that M。
Latour has what seems to him the strongest of motives for confessing
to the murder of John Darrow。 If I am able to do this to your
satisfaction； I shall practically have thrown M。 Latour's entire
testimony out of court； and nothing of importance will then remain
but the evidence of the government's witness； M。 Godin。〃
A great wave of excitement swept over the room at these remarks。
〃What！〃 each said to himself； 〃is it possible that this lawyer will
try to prove that Latour； despite his circumstantial confession；
did not commit the murder after all？〃 We did not dare let such a
thought take hold of us； yet could not see what else could explain
Maitland's remarks。 Is it any wonder； therefore； that we all waited
breathlessly for him to continue？ M。 Godin's face was dark and
lowering。 It was evident he did not propose to have his skill as a
detective； … and with it the Darrow reward； … set aside without a
struggle … at least so it seemed to me。 The room was as quiet as
the grave when Maitland continued。
〃I shall show you that M。 Godin's testimony is utterly unreliable；
and； moreover； that it is intentionally so。〃
This was a direct accusation； and at it M。 Godin's face became of
ashen pallor。 I felt that he was striving to control his anger and
saw the effort that it cost him as he fastened Maitland with a
stiletto…like look that was anything but reassuring。 George did
not appear to notice it and continued easily：
〃I shall prove to you beyond a doubt that； in the actual murder of
John Darrow； only one person was concerned； … by which I mean； that
only one person was outside the east window when he met his death。
I shall also show that M。 Latour was not； and could not by any
possibility have been； that person。 ＇At this juncture Browne arose
and walked toward the door。 He was very pale and looked anything
but well。 I thought he was going to leave； but he reseated himself
at the back of the room near the door。＇ I shall convince you that
M。 Latour's description of the way the murder was committed is false。〃
All eyes were turned toward Latour； but he made no sign either of
affirmation or dissent。 With his eyes closed and his hands falling
listlessly in front of him； he sat in a half…collapsed condition；
like one in a stupor。 M。 Godin shifted uneasily in his chair； as
if he could not remain silent much longer。 Maitland proceeded with
calm deliberation：
〃Mr。 Clinton Browne … 〃
But he did not finish the sentence。 At the name 〃Mr。 Clinton Browne〃
he was interrupted by a sudden commotion at the rear of the room；
followed by a heavy fall which shook the whole apartment。 We all
turned and looked toward the door。 Several men had gathered about
someone lying upon the floor； and one of them was throwing water in
the face of the prostrate man。 Presently he revived a little； and
they bore him out into the cooler air of the corridor。 It was
Clinton Browne。 The great tension of the trial； his own strong
emotions； and the closeness of the room had doubtless been too much
for him。 I could not but marvel at it； however。 Here were delicate
women with apparently little or no staying power； and yet this
athlete； with the form of a Mars and the fibre of a Hercules； must
be the first to succumb。 Verily； even physicians are subject to
surprises！
When quiet had been fully restored Maitland continued：
〃I was about to say when the interruption occurred that Mr。 Clinton
Browne and Mr。 Charles Herne would both testify to the fact that a
very sensible time elapsed between the delivery of the blow and the
death of the victim。 You will see； therefore； that I shall prove to
your satisfaction that Mr。 Darrow's death did not result from prussic
acid； as stated by the prisoner。 I shall show you that a chemical
analysis of the wound made in my laboratory shortly after the murder
gave none of the well…known prussic…acid reactions。 I shall prove
to you that John Darrow sprang to his feet after receiving the blow
which caused his death。 That he clutched at his throat； and that；
after an effort consuming several seconds； he spoke disjointedly。
I shall convince you that if he had been poisoned in the manner
described he would have been dead before he could have so much as
raised his hand to his throat。 We have been very particular to
make sure the exact nature of the poison which it is claimed was
used； so there can be no possible doubt upon this point。 I shall
show you further that the little Capucin monkey which M。 Latour says
he killed is still alive； and I will produce him； if necessary； and
will challenge M。 Latour； or anyone else for that matter； to put him
through the drill which it is claimed he has been taught。 I shall
inform you that； since I claim the monkey had no part in Mr。 Darrow's
death； I could not； during my examination of the prisoner； have been
stating anything from knowledge when I spoke of the manner in which
he had trained the animal； and gave details which M。 Latour accepted
as those of the murder。 My sole effort was to state a plausible way；
in order to see if the prisoner would not adopt it as the actual
course pursued。 I also coupled with this the killing of the monkey
（though I knew the animal was still alive）； that I might see if M。
Latour would follow my lead in this also。 You have seen that he did
so； that he indorsed my guesses where they were purely guesses； and
that he also accepted the one statement I knew to be false。 I shall
therefore ask you to consider about what the chances are that a
series of guesses like those which I made would represent the exact
facts as M。 Latour has claimed； while at the same time you do not
lose sight of the undeniable fact that upon the only detail regarding
which I had positive information； M。 Latour bore false testimony。〃
Here Maitland whispered to Jenkins； who in turn spoke to the sheriff
or some other officer of the court。 I would have given a good deal
just then to have been able to translate M。 Godin's thoughts。 His
face was a study。 Maitland immediately resumed：
〃It has been positively stated by M。 Latour that he gambled with Mr。
Darrow on Decatur Street between the 1st and 15th day of March。 This
is false。 In the first place it can be shown that while Mr。 Darrow
occasionally played cards at his own home； he never gambled；
uniformly refusing to play for even the smallest stake。 Furthermore；
Mr。 Darrow's physician will testify that Mr。 Darrow was confined
to his bed from the 25th day of February to the 18th day of March；
and that he visited him during that time at least once； and oftener
twice； every day。
〃Again； M。 Latour asserts that he never saw M。 Godin till the day
of his arrest； and M。 Godin asserts that he never entered M。 Latour's
rooms until that day。 I have a photograph and here a phonographic
record。 The picture shows M。 Latour's rooms with that gentleman and
M。 Godin sitting at a table and evidently engaged in earnest
conversation。 This cylinder is a record of a very interesting
portion of that conversation … M。 Godin will please not leave the
room！〃
This last was said as M。 Godin started toward the door。 The officer
to whom Jenkins had recently spoken laid his hand upon the detective
and detained him。 〃We may need M。 Godin；〃 Maitland continued； 〃to
explain things to us。
〃I invite your attention to the fact that M。 Godin has testified
that he was assisted in his search for Mr。 Darrow's murderer by
certain library slips which he saw M。 Latour make out in two
different names。 He has also testified that he did not know even
the names of any of the books procured on these slips； and that
one of them； entitled 'Poisons； Their Effects and Detection；' he
not only never read； but never even heard of。 I shall show you
that all of these books were procured with M。 Godin's knowledge；
and that most of them were read by him。 I shall prove to you
beyond a doubt that he has not only heard of this particular work
on poisons； but that he has read it and placed his unmistakable
signature on page 469 thereof beside the identical paragraph which
suggested to Mr。 Darrow's murderer the manner of his assassination！〃
M。 Godin started as if he had been stabbed； but quickly regained
his self…control as Maitland continued： 〃Here is the volume in
question。 You will please note the thumb…mark in the margin of page
469。 There is but one thumb in the world that could have made that
mark； and that is the thumb you have seen register itself upon this
letter。 It is also the thumb that made this paint smutch upon this
slip of glass。〃
All eyes were turned upon M。 Godin。 He was very pale； yet his jaw
was firmly set and something akin to a defiant smile played about
his handsome mouth。 To say that the audience was amazed is to convey
no adequate idea of their real condition。 We felt prepared for
anything。 I almost feared lest some sudden turn in the case might
cast suspicion upon myself； or even Maitland。 Without apparently
noticing M。 Godin's discomfiture； George continued：
〃M。 Godin has testified that he sometimes plays cards； but only for
a small stake … just enough； he says； to make it interesting。 I
shall show you that he is a professional gambler as well as a
detective。
〃The morning after the murder was committed I made a most careful
examination of the premises； part